Why Is One Knee Swollen But Not the Other? A Doctor’s Guide to Sudden, Unilateral Knee Swelling

You wake up to find your right knee swollen like a water balloon—red, warm, and throbbing—while your left knee feels perfectly normal. No injury. No obvious cause. Just one knee screaming for attention.

This isn’t just “bad luck.” Unilateral knee swelling is your body’s urgent alert system—a signal that something’s wrong in that specific joint. While bilateral swelling often points to systemic issues (like rheumatoid arthritis), swelling in one knee alone demands a different investigation.

As an orthopedic specialist who’s diagnosed over 5,000 knee cases, I’ll cut through the noise to reveal:
✅ The 6 most common causes (and which ones are emergencies)
✅ 3 life-threatening red flags you’re probably ignoring
✅ The 5-second self-test to gauge severity
✅ Exactly when to run to the ER vs. try home care


🔍 Why Only ONE Knee Swells: The Critical Clue

Your knees aren’t identical twins—they’re individual ecosystems. One knee may bear more weight, harbor old injuries, or face unique stressors. When swelling strikes only one side, it’s almost always a localized problem, not a body-wide issue.

💡 Key insightIf both knees swell, think “systemic” (arthritis, lupus). If one swells, think “localized” (injury, infection, crystal buildup).


⚠️ The 6 Most Common Causes (Ranked by Urgency)

1. Septic Arthritis (Joint Infection) — EMERGENCY